Did You Know Jim Carrey Almost Played Buddy In Will Ferrell’s Elf? (Photo Credit – Prime Video)
Advertisement
Elf without Will Ferrell feels impossible, right? His silly charm, wide-eyed wonder, and laugh-out-loud lines made it a holiday favorite. But guess what? He wasn’t even the first pick for Buddy! In the early ‘90s, when Elf was just a Hollywood daydream, another comedy icon was set to play Buddy.
That actor had a chaotic energy, a super-expressive face, and a history of playing quirky characters. It seemed like a perfect fit (until it wasn’t). By the time Elf got made, the first-choice actor was long gone, leaving the role wide open. That twist of fate brought in Ferrell, and the rest is history. But who nearly became Buddy Hobbs? And would Elf still be the same holiday gem if that had happened? Let’s rewind to where it all began.
Another Comedy Legend Who Almost Played Buddy Before Will Ferrell
Before Will Ferrell brought Buddy Hobbs to life, Elf had another star in mind. That star is none other than Jim Carrey. With blockbuster hits like Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, The Mask, and Dumb and Dumber, Carrey was known for his elevated performances during that era.
Moreover, a human raised by elves, spreading boundless cheer in New York? That seemed tailor-made for Jim Carrey’s style. His enthusiastic, over-the-top comedy was a perfect match for Buddy. He had already shown he could plunge into quirky roles, so playing a giant elf appeared right up his alley. The producers deemed him the soundest fit, and for a time, it seemed like he would be the one to bring Buddy to life.
But things took an unforeseen path. By the early 2000s, as Elf prepared for filming, Jim Carrey had moved on. He had recently played another prominent Christmas character—The Grinch in How the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000). With that film’s tremendous success, he wasn’t eager to swoop into another holiday role so soon.
With Carrey out, Buddy’s role was up for grabs. That’s when the studio looked to Ferrell, a rising star from Saturday Night Live. Though Ferrell was known for his comedy, he hadn’t proven himself as a box-office draw. Leading a significant holiday film was a bold bet.
But as soon as Will Ferrell put on the elf suit, everything clicked. His performance brought something extraordinary to Buddy—refined and naive combined with hilarious physical comedy. Audiences fell in love, and Elf earned over $230 million worldwide (reported by Box Office Mojo), evolving into a holiday staple.
