Why Did Patrick Stewart Almost Turn Down The Role Of Professor X? (Photo Credit – Instagram)
Advertisement
Sir Patrick Stewart almost turned down the role of Professor Charles Xavier in X-Men—and it’s all thanks to Star Trek. In the late ’90s, Stewart was a well-established sci-fi icon, having played Jean-Luc Picard in The Next Generation. But, when Bryan Singer pitched him the role of Professor X for the X-Men movie, Stewart had doubts. His main concern? He didn’t want to be stuck playing two similar roles.
According to Screen Rant, Stewart wondered, “Would the audiences get confused? Would I get confused?” At the time, he avoided the overlap between Picard’s calm, composed leadership and Xavier’s cerebral, authoritative persona. Stewart almost passed on the role, thinking his Star Trek stint was enough sci-fi for one lifetime. But Singer wasn’t having it. He reassured Stewart that the only real similarity would be their “head shapes.”
Fast forward to 2000, and Patrick Stewart’s portrayal of Professor X became one of the most iconic superhero performances ever. But what’s remarkable is how his time as Picard subtly informed his take on Xavier. Both characters are leaders but with distinct personalities. While Picard was often about calm, collected command, Xavier blended compassion with authority. Stewart used the same grounded leadership skills he honed as Picard, but Professor X allowed him to stretch his emotional range—something Star Trek didn’t demand quite as much.
Despite their similarities, Stewart’s roles couldn’t be more different. Picard’s bravado was more about intellect, while Xavier’s was rooted in empathy. Yet, as the years went on, Stewart’s portrayal of Xavier evolved, mirroring some of the subtle traits he developed as Picard. A cool, wise leader, sure—but one with layers of vulnerability. That blend of authority and compassion became Stewart’s signature in both universes.
Still, Stewart almost turned down X-Men altogether. “I didn’t want to play another fantasy role,” he admitted. The actor felt the role might be too similar to Picard, which could’ve led to some redundancy in his career. But in hindsight, he made the right choice. The success of X-Men gave Stewart a new lease on his career, setting the stage for over two decades of Professor X portrayals. And in the process, Stewart became a staple in superhero cinema.
Years later, as Star Trek: Picard debuted, Patrick Stewart revisited his past but with fresh eyes. When producers pitched the show in 2018, Stewart was adamant about not returning to Picard’s shoes, saying he’d already explored every aspect of the character. Yet, the team convinced him by offering a new perspective: “30 years have passed for Picard too,” they explained. The character’s reinvention felt necessary, and Stewart returned to the captain’s chair.
What makes Stewart’s career truly special is his ability to take roles and make them distinct. He’s not just returning to old ground; he’s finding new angles, breathing life into characters that could’ve become repetitive. For Stewart, the key to avoiding that trap lies in the script. “It has to be new,” he said, emphasizing that original material keeps his portrayals fresh.
Looking back, X-Men and Star Trek made Sir Patrick Stewart one of the most memorable figures in sci-fi and superhero cinema. What started as a reluctance to take on another leadership role turned into a defining part of his legacy—and, in many ways, made him better in both of those iconic roles.
