Did Sutton Foster’s 2019 Post Foreshadow Her Romance With Hugh Jackman? Theories Explored Amid Affair Rumors
Sutton Foster and Hugh Jackman’s long-speculated relationship is being seen in a new light with Sutton's past cryptic post and Hugh’s old "cheating" tweet resurfacing amid their growing romance.
Sutton Foster & Hugh Jackman’s Old Cryptic Posts Go Viral Amid Romance Rumors ( Photo Credit – Instagram )
Advertisement
Years before Sutton Foster and Hugh Jackman’s romance became public, a seemingly innocent social media post by Sutton appeared to foreshadow their eventual relationship amid swirling rumors of an affair.
The Broadway stars, who went public with their romance this week, had long been the subject of speculation following the end of their respective marriages.
Jackman, 56, and Foster, 49, first crossed paths in 2008 when she starred in Shrek the Musical, but their bond truly deepened during their 2022 Broadway collaboration in The Music Man.
A Playful ‘Cheating’ Post That Took On New Meaning
In 2019, Sutton hinted at the future with a cryptic post that would later gain new meaning. Announcing their casting in the 1962 musical, she cleverly referenced one of its songs, sharing the message, “Til there was Hugh.”
This foreshadowed the connection that would later bloom into a romantic relationship. Coincidentally, this post resurfaced just hours after Hugh Jackman‘s 2015 tweet about “cheating” took on a new life of its own.
In the tweet, Hugh shared a playful image of himself contemplating a plate of cookies, quipping, “To cheat or not to cheat — that is the question?!” He referred to the dilemma of indulging in a cheat meal while dieting.
However, with his relationship with Sutton now public, social media users couldn’t resist commenting on how the tweet “aged poorly” in light of the ongoing affair rumors.
Hugh Jackman & Sutton Foster Publicly Confirmed Their Relationship
Amid the attention, rumors about Hugh Jackman’s romance with Sutton intensified following the end of his 27-year marriage to Deborra-Lee Furness in September 2023. Hugh and Sutton’s chemistry on stage dates back to 2020, when they first started working on The Music Man, which only fueled speculation about their closeness.
Fans were quick to draw parallels between the old “cheating” post and the growing affair rumors, poking fun at how the tweet now seemed almost prescient. Sutton and Hugh made their relationship official on Monday, stepping out hand-in-hand for a dinner date in Santa Monica. The public display of affection confirmed what many had long suspected.
Sources close to Deborra-Lee, 68, indicated that she felt a sense of relief now that the truth was out, confirming the suspicions that had been gnawing at her. “She trusted her intuition, and it was right,” a source revealed. “She can now fully close this chapter and move on.’.”
Being married to you Deb is as natural as breathing. From nearly the moment we met … I knew our destiny was to be together. In our 25 years – our love has only grown deeper. I love with my whole heart. @Deborra_leepic.twitter.com/Dg56vzS4x3
Both Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster had recently ended long-term marriages—Hugh’s to Deborra-Lee and Sutton’s to her ex-husband, Ted Griffin, with whom she shares a daughter.
