Barroz: 3 Reasons Why Mohanlal’s Big Gamble On Christmas Day May Have Trouble Living Up To The Hype
Barroz: Mohanlal’s directorial debut on Christmas Day 2024 faces high expectations and creative challenges. Can star power and legacy deliver on the hype?
Here’s 3 Reason Why We Think Mohanlal’s Barroz May Falter To Maintain The Hype (Photo Credit – Instagram)
Advertisement
When veteran filmmaker Fazil announced the release date of Mohanlal’s highly anticipated directorial debut, Barroz, the excitement was palpable. Slated to release on Christmas Day, December 25, 2024, the date carries immense sentimental value for both Mohanlal and his career. As Fazil pointed out, this is no ordinary coincidence.
It marks a full-circle moment, as Mohanlal’s acting debut in Manjil Virinja Pookkal (1980), directed by Fazil himself, premiered on December 25th. Fast-forward to 1993, and another Mohanlal starrer, Manichitrathazhu, a cultural phenomenon that was remade in multiple languages, also hit theaters on December 25.
Fazil revealed that Barroz took over 700 days of filming, underscoring the immense effort poured into this project. He also expressed confidence that the film could surpass the success of Manjil Virinja Pookkal and Manichitrathazhu, envisioning it as a global phenomenon. But can Barroz live up to these lofty expectations?
While this release date might seem auspicious, optimism alone doesn’t guarantee success. In this article, we’ll explore three reasons why Barroz might not live up to the hype and whether the weight of past glories could be a double-edged sword for Mohanlal’s ambitious venture.
The Uncertain Path Of Barroz: A Closer Look At Creative Challenges.
While Mohanlal is celebrated as one of India’s finest and most versatile actors, his capabilities as a director remain untested. Barroz, his ambitious directorial debut, carries high expectations, but its creative journey has been anything but smooth. Originally scripted by the legendary Jijo Punnoose, known for his groundbreaking works like Padayottam (1982), India’s first indigenously shot 70mm film, and My Dear Kuttichathan (1984), the first Indian 3D film, the project seemed destined for prestige.
However, Punnoose, who reportedly rewrote the script 22 times to perfect it, envisioned the story strongly focusing on a young girl’s character, with Mohanlal’s titular role being secondary. Scheduling conflicts led to a major rewrite by Mohanlal and Kalavoor Ravikumar, altering characters, locations, and scenes. Most of the shooting shifted to indoor sets built at the Navodaya campus in Kochi.
Punnoose has since distanced himself from the project, stating that the revised script now resembles Mohanlal’s previous films, such as Odiyan, Pulimurugan, Lucifer, and Marakkar: Arabikkadalinte Simham. This shift should raise concerns.
Adding to the skepticism is the replacement of Punnoose with Kalavoor Ravikumar, whose filmography pales in comparison. According to IMDb, Ravikumar’s previous works, a television serial and two box-office flops, hardly inspire confidence for a project of this scale and ambition.
Direction is the cornerstone of any film, influencing every creative and technical element, from music to cinematography. With such major shifts in the script and questionable leadership choices, Barroz faces significant hurdles in living up to its monumental expectations.
Sky-High Expectations
The promotional campaign for Barroz has yet to fully take off, which could be a wise decision given the time remaining for promotion. While it’s essential to create buzz, overhyping a film can lead to unrealistic expectations, which even good films may need help to meet. If Barroz is a well-crafted movie, it will naturally gain momentum through positive word-of-mouth, avoiding the pitfalls of excessive pre-release hype.
Mohanlal and the Barroz team should learn from his previous films like Malaikottai Vaaliban, Odiyan, and Marakkar: Lion of the Arabian Sea, where excessive hype inflated expectations to unsustainable levels, leading to disappointment. Overhyping is not a challenge exclusive to Mohanlal or the Malayalam film industry. For instance, films like Indian 2 from Kollywood and Joker: Folie à Deux from Hollywood show how focusing more on spectacle than substance can backfire. A measured, quality-driven promotional strategy would allow Barroz to succeed on its own merits, ensuring it resonates with audiences when it releases.
Is Star Power Enough For Theatrical Success?
As mentioned earlier, Mohanlal is a versatile actor with a massive fan following in Kerala. However, Kerala is a relatively small market, and fans alone cannot guarantee a film’s success. Additionally, fans in Kerala do not offer unconditional support to any actor.
Take, for example, the Tamil film industry, where Vijay’s GOAT: The Greatest of All Time faced heavy criticism after its release and was considered overhyped in the lead-up to its debut. Despite this, it achieved a worldwide gross of INR 464.54 crores, proving it exceeded minimum expectations.
In other film industries, stars can expect a minimum guarantee if their brand image isn’t entirely tarnished. However, Kerala offers less cushion, even for actors with a strong brand image. A clear example of this is Mohanlal’s film Alone, which was a massive failure despite his star power and, according to some reports, didn’t even manage to cross INR 1 crore at the box office.
