Sinead O’Connor Rips Up Pope’s Photo on Live TV: A Controversial Moment Remembered! (Photo Credit – Wikimedia)
Advertisement
It was October 3, 1992, a night that would etch itself into pop culture history. Sinéad O’Connor, the punk spirit wrapped in reluctant pop star clothing, took to the Saturday Night Live stage and did the unthinkable: she ripped up a photo of Pope John Paul II. With each tear—once, twice, thrice—O’Connor’s actions mirrored her turbulent journey through fame, a journey she had never anticipated. Just two years prior, she’d soared to the top with her iconic cover of Prince’s Nothing Compares 2 U, only to find herself at the center of a storm she never requested.
The photo she tore wasn’t just any photo; it was a profoundly personal symbol tied to her fraught relationship with her late mother. O’Connor had promised herself that one day, she would destroy it. That day, she had come. As she held the torn pieces aloft, she was protesting against the rampant child abuse covered up by the Catholic Church in Ireland, a cause she felt passionate about, given her history of abuse. It was a bold, daring act.
Leading up to her SNL appearance, O’Connor had been pretty outspoken about how unhappy she was with the music industry and its demands. Fame was never her goal; instead, she wanted to express the unfiltered truth. After all, in a letter to the Recording Academy, she had once stated, “As artists, I believe our function is to express the feelings of the human race—always to speak the truth.” Her refusal to accept Grammy nominations and awards only solidified her stance against a system focused on “material gain.”
O’Connor had initially pulled out of an earlier SNL episode due to its host, Andrew Dice Clay, known for his misogynistic humor. However, she did make it a point to raise awareness about such issues. During rehearsals, she held up a photo of a Brazilian child killed by police while performing Bob Marley’s War. When the live broadcast came, O’Connor switched gears dramatically. On the word “evil,” she tore the Pope’s photo, looking straight into the camera, and declared, “Fight the real enemy!”
The backlash was severe. Overnight, she became both a pariah and a punchline. Banned for life from SNL, she faced ridicule and scorn across media outlets. Even Madonna, the Queen of Controversy herself, took a jab at O’Connor’s boldness during her own SNL appearance. It seemed everyone had joined the chorus, treating her like “a crazy bitch” for her act of defiance.
Yet, as O’Connor later reflected, that moment of rebellion was ultimately liberating. “Many people think that tearing up the Pope’s photo derailed my career. That’s not how I feel about it,” she wrote in her memoir, Rememberings. Instead, she saw that moment as a reclamation of her identity. “After SNL, I could just be me.”
Fast-forward nearly two decades, and the tide began to turn. In 2010, Pope Benedict XVI formally apologized to victims of abuse within the Church, a belated acknowledgment of the very issues O’Connor had raised. As time went on, the narrative shifted. O’Connor started to reclaim her legacy, aided by the documentary Nothing Compares and the publication of her memoir.
Director Kathryn Ferguson captured the moment perfectly, remembering how O’Connor was “so ahead of her time.” During a screening in Ireland, when her infamous SNL moment played, the audience erupted in cheers, finally recognizing the truth she had tried to unveil decades earlier. It was a reminder that, sometimes, the most profound statements come from the most unexpected places.
