Sarah Jessica Parker’s Big Decision (Photo Credit – Facebook)
Advertisement
Sarah Jessica Parker, iconic as Carrie Bradshaw, almost turned her back on Sex and the City. Ahan. She nearly walked away from the role that became her defining career moment—despite the show eventually becoming a cultural phenomenon. Early on, she was uncertain about committing to a long-running TV series, fearing it would box her in creatively and limit her flexibility.
“I was terrified of it, and not in a good way,” Parker told Interview magazine. She compared the idea of doing a TV series to being trapped in a monotonous lifestyle. Parker worried about losing her creative freedom, saying, “You’d never get better, you’d just get comfortable, and that’s it. And then you’re in people’s homes, and your life changes—you can’t go to the market by yourself and pick your tomatoes.” That’s a far cry from the free-wheeling, gig-hopping spirit she cherished.
But here’s where Matthew Broderick—her actor husband—stepped in as the voice of reason. He encouraged Parker to leap, telling her, “I think you should do this because it’s an excellent part, and you’ve never played one like it. The worst-case scenario is it’ll be successful. Maybe it’ll be collaborative, and you’ll learn something.” Broderick’s advice eventually swayed her. And, as it turned out, he was onto something.
After shooting the pilot, Parker had a moment of doubt again. She even tried negotiating her way out of her contract. Broadway actor Seth Rudetsky revealed in a Playbill column that Parker initially loved the script but was hesitant about committing to a long-term TV commitment. Rudetsky shared, “She tried various ways to get out of it, including telling HBO that she would film three projects for free if they’d release her from her contract!” Talk about going above and beyond.
But HBO wasn’t about to let Parker off the hook. The network convinced her to honor her deal—and, in hindsight, she didn’t regret it. That persistence led to Sex and the City becoming a smash hit with six acclaimed seasons, multiple box-office movies, and a lasting cultural impact. Parker became not just Carrie but a symbol of modern female friendship and empowerment.
Interestingly, Sex and the City almost saw a different cast dynamic. Kristin Davis, who eventually became Charlotte, was considered for Carrie. Author Jennifer Armstrong revealed in Sex and the City and Us that Davis auditioned for the lead role. But she passed after reading the original character description, which included Carrie having “the body of Heather Locklear and the mind of Dorothy Parker.” Davis felt those physical and behavioral descriptions didn’t align with her image. Smoking, swearing, and edgy traits felt too far outside her boundaries.
Sarah Jessica Parker’s reluctance could’ve changed the course of television history. But her willingness to stick with Sex and the City ultimately paid off. She transcended her early hesitations, embracing a role that would define her career and shape pop culture. It became a love letter to friendship, fashion, and finding your place—even when doubt initially threatened to walk away.
So, the next time you rewatch an episode of Sex and the City, remember this: it almost didn’t happen.
