Koimoi Reader ‘Andy Morris’ has shared his thoughts after watching Aamir Khan’s newly released film PK. Check it out right here:

This is not a PK review. I am not a critic nor a filmmaker, so I cannot review a movie. Still I would like to point out some things that I felt while watching PK. Rajkumar Hirani is one of the finest directors of this generation. His ideas and visions inspire all age group. He knows pretty well how to blend his characters into Indian sentimentality. And it is a good thing because it works, every time he shows something on screen.

If you ask me, nobody understands Indian emotions better than Raju Hirani. That being said I did not like PK as much as I should have. Here are some reasons. Of course there will be comparisons. After all you are Raju Hirani. You already gave us not one but three timeless masterpiece. So here it goes:

Can you really feel the protagonist like you did earlier?

Aamir Khan in a still from movie 'PK'
Aamir Khan in a still from movie ‘PK’

Wheather it is a gunda with a golden heart or an aspiring engineer with an ‘all is well’ mantra, you could always feel the main protagonist. You could always relate to them and root for them just after the first scene. They are the soul of the movie. You laugh with them, you cry with them. But for some reason that did not happen with PK. Yes, Aamir Khan is the perfectionist and he is brilliant in every frame. But it was not convincing. It would really help if his inner thoughts were more revealed. If his behavior was more justified. May be a little back story. May be a little explanation. After a while it felt like does it really matter if he goes back to his planet or not!!

Where are the other characters?

Sanjay Dutt, Boman Irani and Anushka Sharma in a still from movie 'PK'
Sanjay Dutt, Boman Irani and Anushka Sharma in a still from movie ‘PK’

To be honest it would be a delight to see Boman Irani as the antagonist. His and every other character other than Anushka Sharma is completely ignored. Actually there is nothing there for anybody in the movie other than Anushka Sharma and Aamir Khan. But that’s not the real problem. The real problem is it felt like there is a character missing. I really missed a ‘circuit’, a ‘Raju Rastogi’ or a ‘Farhan’. Where is the magic of unselfish, witty, heartfelt friendship? Where is that selfless, adorable funny guy who loves our hero unconditionally and never loses his side? Sanjay Dutt is not that character. Even Anushka Sharma is not. I really would not mind spending another thirty minutes of screen space watching that character.

The GODMEN chronicle

Aamir Khan in a still from movie 'PK'
Aamir Khan in a still from movie ‘PK’

I am not going to debate about the whole GOD-MEN propaganda that is going on at present on every social platform because that would be a complete waste of time and space. But if I am not wrong, not long before, we saw a similar GOD-MEN themed movie named OMG Oh My God!, starring Paresh Rawal and Akshay Kumar. And that was one nice movie. The idea of showing the ‘GOD-MEN theme’ might be different but at the end of the day the essence is same. And most of the time while watching PK, my mind went back to Paresh Rawal arguing about god’s existence. So it did not actually do anything other than refreshing the memory of the other movie. Now GOD is not the real problem. It’s the presentation. As far as Raju Hirani’s abilities go I expected much more than this.

The almost final argument

Aamir Khan in a still from movie 'PK'
Aamir Khan in a still from movie ‘PK’

Remember that epic vacuum cup delivery scene from ‘3 Idiots’ or the Jimmy Shergill dying scene followed by Sanjay Dutt’s breakdown from ‘Munnabhai MBBS’? Even the final wedding scene from ‘Lage Raho‘! I still find my heart racing when I see those scenes now. Those scenes were epic because they represent us, our culture not as Indians but as human beings. It is not about our love for a single person but our love for the society. They teach us that we can together make the world a better place. But sadly that scene is missing from PK. A final argument between the two main characters about GOD after the protagonist has a breakdown due to a huge loss and it ends up meeting two other people in love who lost each other due to their own mistakes which has really nothing to do with god. At a point when in ‘lage raho’, munna bhai taught life lessons on radio, I wanted to stand up and clap with every other person in the movie but not here on PK, where the anchor trying to make a phone call to her long lost lover all over the world live on national television. That is just not acceptable. It is off the subject of the whole argument in the first place. It should have stuck with GOD.

Aamir Khan and Sanjay Dutt in a still from movie 'PK'
Aamir Khan and Sanjay Dutt in a still from movie ‘PK’

Nonetheless PK is a good movie. I just hoped I had seen PK before Munnabhai MBBS, Lage Raho and 3 Idiots. Or may be its just me. I guess I need a jadu ki jhappi.

Now, enjoy reading koimoi.com on your Windows Phone, iPhone/iPad and Android Smartphone.

Check This Out

13 COMMENTS

  1. i totally agree with this guy’s few points like the patroganist stuff and the weak screenspace provided to supporting roles but i can easile give reasons for the weakness shown by this review 1 we may not be able to feel the patroganist because of some ignorant things that PK does instead we may feel anuska ,sanjay and sometimes the baraber as the patroganist because they all were humans and PK was not . 2 weak screenspace for supporting actors was just because to reduce the movie length to 2:30min so that some assholes may not complain later on . and we should not complain about the understanding between 2 frnds thats what shown in the whole movie the frndship of jaggu and PK . This creation of raju sir comes with gear heart touching movements and some logical questions that we should have answered before becoming used to them . Each and every movie is not same and if it had the same things as 3 idiots and munnabhai then you would have definitely said that raju copies from his own creation

  2. arey mere bhai Isi hirani ne ferrari ki sawari bhi banyi he Mere bhai ye kamal Hirani bhai saab ka nahi ye aamir ka kamal he Aur Mere bhai Ye amir ka bhi kamal nahi ye to ooski face value ka he Aur bura mat maan na Amir pichli film Dhoom 3 ek bakwas movie thi

  3. As always, Raju Hirani and Amir Khan have more than delivered. I expect the movie to do extremely well at the box office. Any movie that, with sensitivity, makes you think, ponder is worth its salt. Keep it up Raju Hirani. Keep it up Amir Khan. we need a sequel soon.

  4. I think we should stop nitpicking and appreciate a really good work. Personally speaking i liked pk more than 3 idiots. This movie is more universal and much more sensitive one.There was bound to be some sentimentality. It has handled a tough message with such delicacy that it’s sheerly wonderful

  5. Stupid article or whatever. He is trying to relate and compare diff. movies and diff. character personalities. Seems like he has no work to do :D

  6. Its time Raju Hirani moved on and did something different. How long will he keep recycling the same formula that he brought in in Munnabhai MBBS.
    PK is a good movie, but there’s a feeling of ‘seen-that’ throughout. its just like ticking boxes.
    Lets see if Raju Hirani can excel with another genre.

  7. You are not the only one who feels like this Andy I agree with you pk isn’t the level of raju hirani. He does more better than this. I am quite disappointed with pk.

  8. I totally agree with review, For some time I felt like I was watching a sequel of OMG. But still I enjoyed all 2:30 hours and my attention was never diverted from movie however I didn’t expected to watch OMG in PK as Hirani is known for fresh ideas

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here